Beardo: He was a ton of fun to watch, kind of sad he went so early. But it does make sense.
Leonard: He was kind of funny at first, but got annoying fast.
Amy: Annoying, but still an interesting character because of her dynamic with Samey. I wish the twins had stayed longer in general.
Rodney: He was pretty funny. The shtick kind of got old at moments, but the funny moments outweighed the not-so-funny moments.
Samey: She might've been my favorite character, actually, just because of how relate-able she was. I was pretty upset she went so early, but seeing her get her revenge was very satisfying.
Ella: Maybe not the most realistic character, but I liked her a lot. A lot of fun to watch, and her last song was cool.
Topher: Pretty neutral on him. Didn't hate him, didn't like him that much, kind of wish he'd gone earlier than he did.
Dave: I was told he was supposed to be "the normal guy", which I liked the idea of, but he wasn't executed that well. He seemed more like just an overall jerk and wimp, and Sky liking him seemed a bit forced and unrealistic. (although he did make a prostitution joke on a CARTOON NETWORK show so I can't be too hard on him)
Scarlett: I wish I hadn't been spoiled about her being a villain so early, because I generally love villain reveals in movies, tv shows and games. Maybe a bit TOO evil to be realistic, but I like what they did with her.
Max: Not a very realistic character, but funny. I always thought they should include a "wannabe villain", and so I'm glad he was added.
Jasmine: She was an interesting character, all things considered. I don't have too much bad to say about her.
Sugar: She was just annoying, and lasted way longer than she should have. Seeing her embarrass herself at the end was kind of a good payoff, but I still didn't like her.
Sky: I've heard people describe her as "Zoey but without the bad parts", and I think that's a good description. I liked her, but she still had realistic flaws.
Shawn: Funny character. Maybe not too realistic, but some of the best moments on the show came from him, and I think he was deserving of a win.