View Poll Results: Who won?

Voters
3. You may not vote on this poll
  • Thanos dropped him like he did to his daughter!

    0 0%
  • Oppenheimer split him like 2 and 3 from 5!

    3 100.00%
Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123
Results 21 to 26 of 26

Thread: Thanos vs J. Robert Oppenheimer Discussion

  1. #21
    Right?! The moment I saw Thanos in this ERB I just...wow and here I thought Thanos' lines were bad. Just wow he looks like a cheap costume you buy at the store.


    RIP Leslie Neilson
    1926 - 2010
    "Yes I am serious and don't call me shirley"

  2. #22
    thanos looks pretty off but I'm sure he's a really hard character to portray well without a massive budget... after watching the behind the scenes I can tell they did their very best with what they had. at first his eyes bothered me but then I realized they were probably going for a more comic book inspired appearance with the black shadow eyes, so I'll give it a pass overall. I mean, the guy is supposed to be ugly... but it would definitely be more appealing if it had better mouth movement.

    aside from the questionable thanos costume I think the visuals for this battle were pretty damn stunning. everything about oppenheimer visually was great, I love how pete portrayed him (that thousand yard stare...) and the backgrounds and effects were mesmerizing
    Last edited by Justinian I; 12-18-2019 at 08:37 PM.

  3. #23
    Yeah the only way I could imagine them doing it well is if they had some kind of animatronic maybe and that would have been way too expensive for a short five minute video same goes for extensive CGI.


    RIP Leslie Neilson
    1926 - 2010
    "Yes I am serious and don't call me shirley"

  4. #24
    Samos's Avatar Super Moderator
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Maryland, United States
    Posts
    7,162
    Blog Entries
    32
    Oppenheimer was amazing, everything I was hoping for lyrically and visually. Thanos does not look good, unfortunately. Still love this battle for its lyrics though.

    If you want me to review something of yours, click me.
    Spoiler: 


    We're all humans, we all make mistakes, but try to always keep the site rules in mind..

    Things on here I found funny:
    Spoiler: 
    Quote Originally Posted by PolarBore
    Quote Originally Posted by Sambama
    Quote Originally Posted by Dion
    wumbo write anotherfanfic now
    have nice peter come in
    "it's nice peter bitches"
    ""and i'm going to give you all my NICE PETER"
    and then peter visits the forum
    Quote Originally Posted by Dion
    Quote Originally Posted by Wumbo
    Quote Originally Posted by zyroda View Post
    there was a girl though once she told me she loved me she used to tell me that all the time
    she had this really adorable dog
    it was a boxer and it used to bark really loudly and throw howls in the night and never shut up and it kept her up and night before the big final exam

    and i just wanted her to do well on her exam so i shot the dog
    and all of a sudden im a bad guy

    and you don't love me anymore

    i'm so sorry i guess i never ever do a damn thing right

    everybody thinks i'm gonna cause problems

    nobody wants me with them cause they think i'm gonna do all this weird stuff that's gonna cause problems
    Quote Originally Posted by TDFE Confessional
    Quote Originally Posted by GonadtheNomad
    Quote Originally Posted by Wumbo
    Quote Originally Posted by PolarBore
    Quote Originally Posted by Wumbo
    SENT
    lies
    i never lie
    Honest Wumbabe
    Quote Originally Posted by SuperRapz
    Quote Originally Posted by Rocket
    Gogos are not 4 year old toys, they're a choking hazard.
    You Know What Else Is A Choking Hazard? My Penis. So you Better Stop Sucking On it So hard, Four Year Old. Make A New Thread For your Spam, You Stupid Bitch. We Try To have Fun Here. And Don't Jump On me About MLP, You Stupid little Fuck. Like YN Said, Go Get Tested Or Some Shit. I'm Tired Of Putting Up With You. Pie Licking Bitch, Go Shove A Pickle up Your Ass. Better Yet, A Banana.
    Quote Originally Posted by PolarBore
    Quote Originally Posted by Sambaba
    http://aattp.org/conservative-christian-rewrote-harry-potter-so-her-kids-wont-turn-into-witches/
    I'm not reading past the title

    Quote Originally Posted by Martin Luther King, Jr.
    Let no man pull you low enough to hate him.

  5. #25
    upon a few rewatches, I have mixed feelings about this battle. it has such a great atmosphere to it, it feels more dark and serious, the background visuals feel particularly "epic", and the moral contrast between the two characters is great. but certain things feel tonally out of place. for example, the ant-man line, might be one of my least favourite erb lines of all time.... its just so childish and comes out of nowhere in terms of opp's characterization. and I wish they portrayed thanos a little more seriously, instead of dancing around all goofy and bragging about being in fortnite, I'd like if he was menacingly sitting on his throne, delivering his lines in a more intimidating way. the way lloyd played/voiced him just lacks oomph and comes across too silly imo. which is extra disappointing given pete's amazing performance

    edit because I have a lot of thoughts about this battle apparently:
    I also think the thanos costume would have worked much better if they leaned into his comics design a little more... the same mask but with a helmet would probably have looked better, the shadowy eyes would be more fitting and the shape of his head would be less distracting
    Last edited by Justinian I; 12-19-2019 at 05:44 PM.

  6. #26
    I think they went with the design from his first apperance back in Invincible Iron Man #55 rather than his other looks. I just recall his eyes having the same dark tone in that first comic design.


    RIP Leslie Neilson
    1926 - 2010
    "Yes I am serious and don't call me shirley"

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •