Presidential Reviews

[xxDeadxPoolxx]

Sweet!

[Samos]

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:3tfqp2as]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:3tfqp2as]

[xxDeadxPoolxx]

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:1il3upae]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:1il3upae]

Can you give a break down of your scoring? It doesn't make sense to me.

[BobbyBobber]

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:3if39j7z]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:3if39j7z]

Some of my opinions:
-I think all the costumes where great
-And Robin's voice was pulled off awesomely
-I think the first BM verse SUCKED. I dont think any of the lines where good. This verse was pure comedy IMO.
I agree with everything else.
Also, when you do get to reviewing the Extreme Collab, could you review Hulk vs. Tyson?

[xxDeadxPoolxx]

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:35kes619]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:35kes619]

Some of my opinions:
-I think all the costumes where great
-And Robin's voice was pulled off awesomely
-I think the first BM verse SUCKED. I dont think any of the lines where good. This verse was pure comedy IMO.
I agree with everything else.

Should someone suggest in on my review thread, I'll do it .

[Samos]

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:15uc8z97]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:15uc8z97]

Can you give a break down of your scoring? It doesn't make sense to me.

I don't really know how to break it down. I judge every category out of 10. If it helps:
4 or lower: Bad
5-5.5: Average
6-6.5: Above Average
7-7.5: Enjoyable
8-8.5: Great
9-9.5: Outstanding
10: Perfect

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:15uc8z97]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:15uc8z97]

Some of my opinions:
-I think all the costumes where great
-And Robin's voice was pulled off awesomely
-I think the first BM verse SUCKED. I dont think any of the lines where good. This verse was pure comedy IMO.
I agree with everything else.
Also, when you do get to reviewing the Extreme Collab, could you review Hulk vs. Tyson?

Alright.

[xxDeadxPoolxx]

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:2opnp5xa]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:2opnp5xa]

Can you give a break down of your scoring? It doesn't make sense to me.

I don't really know how to break it down. I judge every category out of 10. If it helps:
4 or lower: Bad
5-5.5: Average
6-6.5: Above Average
7-7.5: Enjoyable
8-8.5: Great
9-9.5: Outstanding
10: Perfect

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:2opnp5xa]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:2opnp5xa]

Some of my opinions:
-I think all the costumes where great
-And Robin's voice was pulled off awesomely
-I think the first BM verse SUCKED. I dont think any of the lines where good. This verse was pure comedy IMO.
I agree with everything else.
Also, when you do get to reviewing the Extreme Collab, could you review Hulk vs. Tyson?

Alright.

The score differences between the total score and the characters scores doesn't seem to add up though.

[Samos]

[quote=Dead.Pool.Castiel]

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:2ccwg0do]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:2ccwg0do]

Can you give a break down of your scoring? It doesn't make sense to me.

I don't really know how to break it down. I judge every category out of 10. If it helps:
4 or lower: Bad
5-5.5: Average
6-6.5: Above Average
7-7.5: Enjoyable
8-8.5: Great
9-9.5: Outstanding
10: Perfect

Here's my review of Batman vs. Sherlock Holmes. Next is Funnybone's Siri vs. GLaDOS Round 2.
[spoiler:2ccwg0do]Beat: I didn’t like this at first, but it’s grown on me a bit. It’s actually quite fitting for a battle between two heroes. It’s a bit slow, but it’s not a bad beat. 7.5/10

Impressions and Costumes: Batman’s voice is OK, Robin’s isn’t that good, Holmes and Watson’s are pretty good. I think the costumes were fine. They were probably trying to do Basil Rathbone’s Sherlock, and I think they pulled it off. 8/10

Batman-Round 1: This verse gets a lot of hate, and I don’t get why. Sure, it’s probably the worst verse of the battle, and the first bit isn’t too good, but it does have some good lines, such as the Bangers and Mash line. Not great, but not as bad as people say it is. 7/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 1: It’s has a nice start when he deduces Batman’s identity with clever lines. The ending is where it gets really good. The British butler line and the ill line are both awesome lines. 8.5/10

Batman and Robin-Round 2: Robin was very impressive. Most of his lines were great, especially the Irene Adler line. Batman’s last line is pretty good, so I consider this a step up. 8.5/10

Sherlock Holmes and Watson-Round 2: The beginning is pretty cool, and the effects are both impressive and funny. The lines that follow are, for the most part, pretty good. 8.5/10


Overall: This battle was actually really enjoyable. Lots of people don’t like Batman’s lines, but that’s only because the rest of season 2 has been so impressive. I can’t really explain why, but this battle is just fun to watch. 8/10

Final Results:
Batman and Robin: 15.5/20
Sherlock Holmes: 17/20

Total Score: 56/70[/spoiler:2ccwg0do]

Some of my opinions:
-I think all the costumes where great
-And Robin's voice was pulled off awesomely
-I think the first BM verse SUCKED. I dont think any of the lines where good. This verse was pure comedy IMO.
I agree with everything else.
Also, when you do get to reviewing the Extreme Collab, could you review Hulk vs. Tyson?

Alright.

The score differences between the total score and the characters scores doesn't seem to add up though.[/quote:2ccwg0do]
If you're talking about the thing at the end where I show each character's scores out of 20, that's just to add up who I thought the winner is and clarify who I thought won. It doesn't add to the total.

For example: Batman's first verse got a 7 and his second got an 8.5. That adds up to 15.5. I put that at the end, but I don't add another 15.5 points to the total score.

[xxDeadxPoolxx]

Ah alright.

[Batman Heisenberg]

Can you switch my Chris Griffin vs Luke Skywalker battle with my batman battle? I think its better, and I want to see how good it is.